If you have any comments or feedback regarding any articles you have read here then feel free to let us know by using the comment box below the relevant articles or sending email to
আলহামদুলিল্লাহ। আপনার লেখা পড়ে যার পর নাই খুশি হয়েছি। আমাদের আনন্দের বিষয় যে, নানামুখি যড়যন্ত্রের শিকার বাংলাদেশকে নিয়ে আপনার দূরদর্শী চিন্তাচেতনা রয়েছে, যা আমাদের স্বাধীনতা ও ঐতিহ্য নিয়ে বেঁচে থাকতে অনুপ্রেরণা যোগাবে। অশেষ ধন্যবাদ। ডঃ হারুন সরকার, ঢাকা, বাংলাদেশ।
Salam to you. Hope you are doing well. I was looking long time for this kind of website. Finally I got it. I have to tell you , you have best knowledge about Quran and Sunnah. Bangladesh is run by man made laws. Which is called sherk. Sherk means there is no Iman. All are Kafirs. Only one party is working there. That is called Jamati Islami. Still they have to obey the constitution. They are doing sherk too. They do not have any choice. Secularism is Haram too. One day, they will reach their destination, Allah will help them. Most of people has no knowledge. Even in Madrasah students.
Please keep the site alive, At least , we can come here, gain knowledge from your writing.
Firoz Kamal lacks true sentiment of Razakar, anti-Islam and secularism in Bangladesh scenario. The Razakar issue is completely of crime against humanity i.e. members of this force who collaborated with Paki military in 1971 have proven track records of murder, loot, rape, arson, etc that has no justification but simple crime against humanity. Yes, there's a section of intellectuals in Bangladesh who are personally involved in secular movement of their own characteristics but the essence they miss is that Islam had no conflict with secularism in true sense that they themselves lack. Same is the case with FM Kamal here, his explanation of attacking Islam while using Razakar tool is not correct in the sense that Razakar and Islam are not the same. If one rationally talks on Islam then they would find Islam won't leave Razakars who killed, raped and loot people in the name of Pakistan.
It is clear to me that you have failed to understand my analysis. You have mentioned that Islam has no conflict with secularism. Such a notion clearly reveals how badly you lack the understandings of Islam as well as secularism. Islam wants to transform not only the individual life, but also families, societies and states and their laws, education and culture according to the Qur'anic teachings. But secularism wants to restrict such influence of a religion in the state and on its law, education and politics. Here starts the conflict between the Islam and secularism. So how can you say these two have no conflict? It is not the place to discuss all these issues with more details. If you wish to know my views in more details, I would ask you to read my articles on secularism in my website.
Secondly, you have described razakars as collaborators of Pakistan army. This is a typical lie of the Awami League propaganda. Razakar is an urdu word. The meaning of razakar is volunteer. They were not the collaborator for any army or a person like Yahia Khan. They fought their own war against the enemies of their own country -which was Pakistan at that time. They never told that the razakars and Islam are the same –as you have mentioned. Islam is a religion and razakars are some motivated people, how a sensible man can think that these two are the same? The razakars simply believed in Pakistan as their homeland, and with that firm belief they volunteered themselves to save that homeland. For that reason, they fought side by side with other Pakistani people and the Pak army. In that war, many of them sacrificed their life, as many Indian people gave their life for India. Is it very difficult to understand this simple act of volunteerism? Anyone has the right to hate them as much they like -as they have the right to hate Pakistan. But one should not tell a lie. I feel you did not read my book "Ekattorer Attogather Itihas". I have discussed this issue in more details there.
You have mentioned that razakars have done crimes like murder, rape and arson. These are old allegations, but not proven so far. Even if you tell these allegations thousands of time, that will not make it true or believable. Along with raising allegation, you must take the burden of proving it in the court. Awami League has been in the government twice, but has failed to prove such allegation during their rule of 9 years. They could not produce any believable documents to the police and the courts. Such allegations are only found in Awami League propaganda. These razakars did not flee to India, Myanmar, Pakistan or any other countries. There were hundreds of thousands of razakars in 1971, and still live in Bangladesh. How many of these razakars have been proven so far to be murderers, rapists or criminals in the court? If you have any proof, instead of raising allegations, you should immedaitely go to the court to file cases against them. If you can prove that allegation in the court, only then we will beleive in your claim. Otherwise, by such accusation, you are proving yourself as a politically motivated false accuser - as are the common practice of Awami League leaders.
Fantastic work. The nation specially a large number of young people are looking for this type of writings so that masses can be aware. But we are so unfortunate that, we do not find much ariticle or writer of such value. I pray to Allah (SWT) for your good health .. Aameen.
As Chomsky puts it, the US has essentially a one party system. In other words, if one insists, the freedom of choice between the Republicans and the Democrats is no less hallucinatory than what it is between Pepsi and Coke. Likewise, Mr. Obama's role is going to be no different than of a CEO to run the Military-Industrial Complex with Zionists and Christian Zionists mostly pulling the strings when it comes to agenda setting. Needless to say, a CEO entitled to run the conglomeration of big businesses makes policies within precisely delineated boundaries of corporate greed, and is far from being a passionate altruist.
Getting carried away by delusional expectations is hailed as positivism by some, but are they really? May Allah make the Muslims true to their faith and purpose-driven, knowledgeable, wise, and diligent in their actions in this life on earth.
Dear Uncle, I have read many articles from many Bangladeshi people, Bangladeshi real scholars or so-called scholars. but i have not found anything as comprehensive as your article. Please write more and more. ALLAH has give you knowledge, inform this knowledge to the illiterate people like us.
Mabrur, Phd Research Scholar, Composite Materials Laboratory, School of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore 639798.
Dear uncle, Salam, i have seen this article from you in nayadiganta also, but in an abridged form, may be the newspaper only printed some portion of your writings. anyway, thanks for the article and all PRAISE TO ALLAH. earlier I visited your website and read almost all the articles; your articles made a one-stop platform to know about many truth; so please send your website links to other people and big Muslim groups of Bangladesh and the world also. Previously I had no knowledge that I could give comment in beneath of every writing; now I am happy to give my comment.
May Allah increase your writing power to inform us other unknown things.
This article is very well-argued and timely indeed. Quite a lot of Muslims are being overjoyed with Obama's victory but they are missing the main issue here. No matter what he may say to present himself as a very liberal politician he will carry on supporting Israel unconditionally as well as doing whatever necessary for his country to dominate the world. May Allah SWT help us all to understand the real motives of America and her allies and give us the strength to oppose that in every way possible.
আমার মনে হয় আপনি পাকিস্তানি অথবা রাজাকার জাতিও কিছু। আপনি কি পাকিস্তানের হয়ে অথবা জংগীদের কিছু করেন। সরাসরি একটি দেশকে অস্বীকার করছে। শুধু শুধু কেন লেখার মাধ্যমে খারাপ বারতা প্রচার করেন। যদি বাঙ্গালী হয়ে থাকেন তবে ভালহয়ে যান, পাকিস্তানের দালালি শেষ করুন। ভারতের জন্যই আমরা বাঙ্গালী। আপনি কি ভুলে গেছেন ভাষা আন্দলন, আর এখন তো লিখেযাচ্ছেন বাংলাতেই। বাংলা শুধু মুসলিমদের নয় সবার। হয় বাংলার পক্ষে বলুন, না হয় আপনার প্রভু সেই পাকিস্তানে চিলে যান।
আপনার প্রবন্ধগুলো খুবই চমৎকার। আমি পড়ে যথেষ্ট উপকৃত হয়েছি। আল্লাহর কাছে প্রার্থনা তিনি আপনাকে আরো বেশী করে লিখে মুসলিম উম্মাহ-কে সতর্ক করার তাওফীক দিন। আপনার দীর্ঘায়ু ও দু জাহানের কল্যাণ কামনায়, আব্দুল্লাহ শহীদ
Assalamu Alaikum, Br. Firoz you are doing an excellent work. However, I have two comments. First, will we ever see a comprehensive compilation of the flip side of the 1971 story - published I mean? This is very important for the current and future generation. Second, how do you deal with the "genocide" allegation? Although the UN has not accepted the "genocide" claim yet (neither did Sarmila Bose) a certain quarter is beating this to an extent that it is circulating widely. On the background of a "genocide" (?) your Islamic explanation of why the loyalists to Pakistan stood up in arms to save Pakistan may still remain in a shaky ground. How do you address the genocide claim? Wassalam, Moin Ahmed.
Dear Br. Moin, Walaikum wassalam. Sorry for not having replied sooner. All praises to Allah SWT that you liked my article. I read your comments and concerns. I have tried to address those issues in the next edition of the book which I finished very recently and will upload on the website very soon. I would request you to go through the new edition which is an enlarged version and more inclusive. If you feel it worthy of dissemination then please do it, at least by forwarding it to your friends. Propagating truth is our collective responsibility. We should co-operate each other. Feel free to share any further opinion. Yours brotherly, Frioz Mahboob Kamal
Br. Firoz you are doing an excellent work by bringing into attention the other side of the 1971 story. I have two comments to make. First, will we ever see any comprehensive compilation of the flip side of the story - published I mean. This is very important for both the current and future generation. Second, this debate of "genocide" has given the whole thing a new twist. Although the UN has not accepted the "genocide" claim (neither did Sarmila Bose) how can this be addressed? Please note that if the other party can establish that a genocide did indeed happen then the efforts to make an Islamic explanation of why pro-Pakistinis stood up in arms for Pakistan will be on a shaky ground. Any comment on this matter? Wassalam.
Comments
As salamu alaikum
Dear brother, how do you do? I am fine. However, I hope you are doing well. I was looking long time for this kind of website. So thank you very much.
May Allah bless you with long life.
আলহামদুলিল্লাহ। আপনার লেখা পড়ে যার পর নাই খুশি হয়েছি। আমাদের আনন্দের বিষয় যে, নানামুখি যড়যন্ত্রের শিকার বাংলাদেশকে নিয়ে আপনার দূরদর্শী চিন্তাচেতনা রয়েছে, যা আমাদের স্বাধীনতা ও ঐতিহ্য নিয়ে বেঁচে থাকতে অনুপ্রেরণা যোগাবে। অশেষ ধন্যবাদ। ডঃ হারুন সরকার, ঢাকা, বাংলাদেশ।
Thanks. May Allah bless you.
Assalamu alikum.
My dear brother how r u? Your website is very nice. So, thanks a lot. Allah Hafez
Dear Brother,
Salam to you. Hope you are doing well. I was looking long time for this kind of website. Finally I got it. I have to tell you , you have best knowledge about Quran and Sunnah. Bangladesh is run by man made laws. Which is called sherk. Sherk means there is no Iman. All are Kafirs. Only one party is working there. That is called Jamati Islami. Still they have to obey the constitution. They are doing sherk too. They do not have any choice. Secularism is Haram too. One day, they will reach their destination, Allah will help them. Most of people has no knowledge. Even in Madrasah students.
Please keep the site alive, At least , we can come here, gain knowledge from your writing.
Fi_Aman Allah
Firoz Kamal lacks true sentiment of Razakar, anti-Islam and secularism in Bangladesh scenario. The Razakar issue is completely of crime against humanity i.e. members of this force who collaborated with Paki military in 1971 have proven track records of murder, loot, rape, arson, etc that has no justification but simple crime against humanity. Yes, there's a section of intellectuals in Bangladesh who are personally involved in secular movement of their own characteristics but the essence they miss is that Islam had no conflict with secularism in true sense that they themselves lack. Same is the case with FM Kamal here, his explanation of attacking Islam while using Razakar tool is not correct in the sense that Razakar and Islam are not the same. If one rationally talks on Islam then they would find Islam won't leave Razakars who killed, raped and loot people in the name of Pakistan.
Secondly, you have described razakars as collaborators of Pakistan army. This is a typical lie of the Awami League propaganda. Razakar is an urdu word. The meaning of razakar is volunteer. They were not the collaborator for any army or a person like Yahia Khan. They fought their own war against the enemies of their own country -which was Pakistan at that time. They never told that the razakars and Islam are the same –as you have mentioned. Islam is a religion and razakars are some motivated people, how a sensible man can think that these two are the same? The razakars simply believed in Pakistan as their homeland, and with that firm belief they volunteered themselves to save that homeland. For that reason, they fought side by side with other Pakistani people and the Pak army. In that war, many of them sacrificed their life, as many Indian people gave their life for India. Is it very difficult to understand this simple act of volunteerism? Anyone has the right to hate them as much they like -as they have the right to hate Pakistan. But one should not tell a lie. I feel you did not read my book "Ekattorer Attogather Itihas". I have discussed this issue in more details there.
You have mentioned that razakars have done crimes like murder, rape and arson. These are old allegations, but not proven so far. Even if you tell these allegations thousands of time, that will not make it true or believable. Along with raising allegation, you must take the burden of proving it in the court. Awami League has been in the government twice, but has failed to prove such allegation during their rule of 9 years. They could not produce any believable documents to the police and the courts. Such allegations are only found in Awami League propaganda. These razakars did not flee to India, Myanmar, Pakistan or any other countries. There were hundreds of thousands of razakars in 1971, and still live in Bangladesh. How many of these razakars have been proven so far to be murderers, rapists or criminals in the court? If you have any proof, instead of raising allegations, you should immedaitely go to the court to file cases against them. If you can prove that allegation in the court, only then we will beleive in your claim. Otherwise, by such accusation, you are proving yourself as a politically motivated false accuser - as are the common practice of Awami League leaders.
Sk Mujib er moto ek "Dictator" kibhabe jatir pita hoi ?
Fantastic work. The nation specially a large number of young people are looking for this type of writings so that masses can be aware. But we are so unfortunate that, we do not find much ariticle or writer of such value. I pray to Allah (SWT) for your good health .. Aameen.
Would you feel happy if India becomes a failed state?
Good writing. Keep it up. All Awami League I see is not human.
আল্লাহ্ আপনার কলমকে আরো শক্তিশালী করুন সত্যের পক্ষে লেখার জন্য।
Assalamu Alaikum
As Chomsky puts it, the US has essentially a one party system. In other words, if one insists, the freedom of choice between the Republicans and the Democrats is no less hallucinatory than what it is between Pepsi and Coke. Likewise, Mr. Obama's role is going to be no different than of a CEO to run the Military-Industrial Complex with Zionists and Christian Zionists mostly pulling the strings when it comes to agenda setting. Needless to say, a CEO entitled to run the conglomeration of big businesses makes policies within precisely delineated boundaries of corporate greed, and is far from being a passionate altruist.
Getting carried away by delusional expectations is hailed as positivism by some, but are they really? May Allah make the Muslims true to their faith and purpose-driven, knowledgeable, wise, and diligent in their actions in this life on earth.
Dear Uncle, I have read many articles from many Bangladeshi people, Bangladeshi real scholars or so-called scholars. but i have not found anything as comprehensive as your article. Please write more and more. ALLAH has give you knowledge, inform this knowledge to the illiterate people like us.
Mabrur, Phd Research Scholar, Composite Materials Laboratory, School of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore 639798.
Dear Uncle, pls forward this article to both secular and islamic groups; nice article.
Dear uncle, Salam, i have seen this article from you in nayadiganta also, but in an abridged form, may be the newspaper only printed some portion of your writings. anyway, thanks for the article and all PRAISE TO ALLAH. earlier I visited your website and read almost all the articles; your articles made a one-stop platform to know about many truth; so please send your website links to other people and big Muslim groups of Bangladesh and the world also. Previously I had no knowledge that I could give comment in beneath of every writing; now I am happy to give my comment.
May Allah increase your writing power to inform us other unknown things.
This article is very well-argued and timely indeed. Quite a lot of Muslims are being overjoyed with Obama's victory but they are missing the main issue here. No matter what he may say to present himself as a very liberal politician he will carry on supporting Israel unconditionally as well as doing whatever necessary for his country to dominate the world. May Allah SWT help us all to understand the real motives of America and her allies and give us the strength to oppose that in every way possible.
আপনার প্রবন্ধগুলো খুবই চমৎকার। আমি পড়ে যথেষ্ট উপকৃত হয়েছি। আল্লাহর কাছে প্রার্থনা তিনি আপনাকে আরো বেশী করে লিখে মুসলিম উম্মাহ-কে সতর্ক করার তাওফীক দিন। আপনার দীর্ঘায়ু ও দু জাহানের কল্যাণ কামনায়, আব্দুল্লাহ শহীদ
Assalamu Alaikum, Br. Firoz you are doing an excellent work. However, I have two comments. First, will we ever see a comprehensive compilation of the flip side of the 1971 story - published I mean? This is very important for the current and future generation. Second, how do you deal with the "genocide" allegation? Although the UN has not accepted the "genocide" claim yet (neither did Sarmila Bose) a certain quarter is beating this to an extent that it is circulating widely. On the background of a "genocide" (?) your Islamic explanation of why the loyalists to Pakistan stood up in arms to save Pakistan may still remain in a shaky ground. How do you address the genocide claim? Wassalam, Moin Ahmed.
Dear Br. Moin, Walaikum wassalam. Sorry for not having replied sooner. All praises to Allah SWT that you liked my article. I read your comments and concerns. I have tried to address those issues in the next edition of the book which I finished very recently and will upload on the website very soon. I would request you to go through the new edition which is an enlarged version and more inclusive. If you feel it worthy of dissemination then please do it, at least by forwarding it to your friends. Propagating truth is our collective responsibility. We should co-operate each other. Feel free to share any further opinion. Yours brotherly, Frioz Mahboob Kamal
Assalamu Alaikum,
Br. Firoz you are doing an excellent work by bringing into attention the other side of the 1971 story. I have two comments to make. First, will we ever see any comprehensive compilation of the flip side of the story - published I mean. This is very important for both the current and future generation. Second, this debate of "genocide" has given the whole thing a new twist. Although the UN has not accepted the "genocide" claim (neither did Sarmila Bose) how can this be addressed? Please note that if the other party can establish that a genocide did indeed happen then the efforts to make an Islamic explanation of why pro-Pakistinis stood up in arms for Pakistan will be on a shaky ground. Any comment on this matter? Wassalam.